Healthiest dairy free yogurt (that actually taste good)

Healthy dairy free yogurt that tastes good is hard to find. I went to two stores and spent $50 trying dairy-free yogurt so that you don’t have to! 

I know a lot of families either have to do dairy-free or choose to do dairy-free. And the yogurt options are all over the board. Some of them are nutritionally similar to yogurt, some of them are really not. 

I evaluated the yogurt on nutrition criteria before choosing 12 to buy and taste test. 

Read through to see my top dietitian recommendations for healthy dairy free yogurt! Or watch the full YouTube review to see my full notes and reactions to each yogurt I tried.

Less nutritious dairy free yogurt options

Right off the bat, I excluded several of the dairy free yogurts that are in many grocery stores. I excluded these because the nutrition is not where I want it. I like to see at least 4 to 5g of protein for fullness, and for your little one’s growth. And I like to see less than 12g of added sugar. Ideally, it would be even lower, but that’s hard to come by with nondairy yogurts that don’t taste like glue. These are the ones that fell short of my nutrition standards for yogurt: 

  • So Delicious DF Coconut Milk Blueberry / <1g protein / 17g sugar / 16g added sugar
  • So Delicious DF Coconut Milk Vanilla / 0g protein / 15g sugar / 15g added sugar
  • Almond Breeze Strawberry / 2g protein / 16g sugar / 15g added sugar
  • Silk Almondmilk Strawberry / 5g protein / 13g sugar / 12g added sugar
  • Silk Almondmilk Vanilla / 5g protein / 15g sugar / 15g added sugar
  • Oui DF Coconut Yogurt Vanilla   / 1g protein / 12g sugar  / 11g added sugar
  • GoGurt DF Coconut Base   / <1g protein  / 16g sugar / 16g added sugar
  • Chobani Coconut Strawberry  / <1g protein / 10g sugar / 8g added sugar
  • Chobani Coconut Blueberry / <1g protein / 11g sugar / 9g added sugar
  • Gt’s Living Foods Cocoyo Living Coconut / 1g protein / 2g sugar / 0g added sugar
  • Culina Dairy Free Coconut, Blueberry Lavender / 2g protein / 9g sugar / 8g added sugar
  • Kite Hill Plant Based Yogurt / 3g protein / 12g sugar / 11g added sugar
  • Kite Hill Protein Yogurt / I only didn’t include this one because the protein is soy protein isolate. I’m not anti-soy (see this post) but I don’t like soy derivatives for nutrition reasons.

Don’t freak out if your favorite is on this list. Just think of it more as a treat than as a replacement for traditional yogurt.

Best tasting & healthy dairy free yogurt

I ranked from best tasting (to worst tasting…like glue…eeek!) here. I wasn’t able to test every flavor for each brand because I was limited by what was in store. If you’ve tried one that I didn’t include here, leave a comment to share if you liked it or not!

Oatly Peach: 8/10

oatly oatgurt review best nondairy yogurt

Nutrition:  160 calories / 7g fat / 3g protein / 12g sugar / 11g added sugar

Ingredients:  Oatmilk (water, oats), peach fruit jam (water, peaches, cane sugar, tapioca starch, pectin, natural flavor, lemon juice concentrate, beta carotene (color), annatto (color), citric acid), low erucic acid rapeseed oil, potato starch. Contains 2% or less of: dextrose, pea protein, potato protein, calcin carbonate, guar gum, tricalcium phosphate, locust bean gum, live active cultures (S. thermophilus, L. bulgaricus, L. casei, L. acidophilus, and B. lactis)

Smell: faint peach smell

Taste: Very thin with some little bits of peach throughout. Nice smooth texture and good flavor! This is my favorite! I would actually eat a whole container of this. The sugar is on the higher side but I’m okay with this amount, given how hard it is to find good tasting dairy free yogurt that is low in sugar! I haven’t tried their other flavors yet since my store didn’t carry them, but you can check them out here.

Siggi’s Coconut Blend Raspberry: 7/10

siggis coconut blend yogurt non dairy yogurt review

Nutrition:  180 calories / 7g fat / 10g protein / 8g sugar / 7g added sugar

Ingredients: Coconut Milk (Water, Coconut Cream), Pea Protein, Raspberries, Cane Sugar, Coconut Oil, Macadamia Nuts, Tapioca Flour, Fruit Pectin, Natural Flavor, Live Active Cultures(S. thermophilus, L. delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus, L. plantarum, L. acidophilus, B. lactis)

Allergens: Tree Nuts (Coconut, Macadamia) 

Smell: Not much of a smell

Taste: It’s not completely smooth, it has tiny bits but it doesn’t feel sandy, if that makes sense. I can taste the macadamia nuts, but I like it. It gives it a fuller flavor. There’s not a strong coconut taste. There’s a bit of texture, with what I think are raspberry seeds, just FYI if your little one gets weird about texture differences. It doesn’t leave as much of a dry feeling in my mouth as most of the others. Pretty good.

Siggi’s Coconut Blend Vanilla and Cinnamon: 7/10

Nutrition:  190 calories / 7g fat / 10g protein / 9g sugar / 8g added sugar

Ingredients: Coconut Milk (Water, Coconut Cream), Pea Protein, Cane Sugar, Coconut Oil, Macadamia Nuts, Tapioca Flour, Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla, Fruit Pectin, Natural Flavor, Cinnamon, Live Active Cultures (S. thermophilus, L. delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus, L. plantarum, L. acidophilus, B. lactis)

Allergens: Tree Nuts (Coconut, Macadamia) 

Smell: solid cinnamon aroma

Taste: Pretty good! Tastes like what you expect it to. Still not quite the same as regular yogurt, but I would willingly eat this one.

Nancy’s Oatmilk Vanilla: 7/10

nancy's oatmilk non-dairy yogurt review vanilla non dairy yogurt

Nutrition:  100 calories / 1.5g fat / 6g protein / 7g sugar / 6g added sugar

Ingredients: Oatmilk(Water, Whole Oat Flour), Faba Bean Protein, Organic Cane Sugar, Tapioca Flour, Coconut Oil, Vanilla Natural Flavor, Vanilla Extract, Agar, Citric Acid, Live Non-Dairy Yogurt Cultures(S. thermophilus, L. bulgaricus)

Smell: just smells like vanilla

Taste: It tastes very sweet, which was surprising because it doesn’t have much added sugar. Very vanilla-y. A little bit of an aftertaste but nothing major. It’s good! The texture is a little funny, when you stir it up it looks a little lumpy but it’s smooth in your mouth. Not a reason to avoid it, just something I noticed!

Silk Greek Blueberry with Coconutmilk: 6.5/10

silk nondairy greek style coconutmilk yogurt review

Nutrition:  190 calories / 11g fat / 10g protein / 9g sugar / 9g added sugar

Ingredients: Coconutmilk (Filtered Water, Coconut Cream), Pea Protein, Cane Sugar, Water, Blueberries, Blueberry Puree Concentrate, Natural Flavor, Pectin, Starch, Fruit and Vegetable Juice (For Color), Calcium Phosphate, Citric Acid, Live and Active Cultures, Vitamin D2.

Allergens: Contains Coconut

Smell: smells like blueberries

Taste: Very thick, like a thick frosting. It tastes very sweet, and sort of artificial with the blueberry taste, but I’m sensitive to that kind of thing. It gives a bit of a dry cottonmouth feeling but it’s not bad. There is an aftertaste too. Marginally better than the vanilla.

Silk Greek Vanilla with Coconutmilk: 6/10

Nutrition:  200 calories / 11g fat / 10g protein / 12g sugar / 12g added sugar

Ingredients: Coconutmilk (Filtered Water, Coconut Cream), Cane Sugar, Pea Protein, Water, Pectin, Natural Flavor, Calcium Phosphate, Citric Acid, Live and Active Cultures, Vitamin D2.

Allergens: Contains Coconut

Smell: Smells like regular vanilla yogurt! 

Taste: It does have some coconut flavor, along with the vanilla. Smooth and thick, no lumps. A bit of an aftertaste, and a little bit thick and pasty feeling in my mouth. It’s not bad. I can’t say I’d exactly look forward to it but it’s decent.

Forager Greek Style Vanilla: 5/10

Nutrition:  170 calories / 8g fat / 6g protein / 10g sugar / 9g added sugar

Ingredients: Coconutmilk (Filtered Water, Coconut Cream*), Cashewmilk (Filtered Water, Cashews*), Cane Sugar*, Protein Blend (Watermelon Seed Protein*, Pumpkin Seed Protein*, Brown Rice Protein*), Tapioca Starch*, Locust Bean Gum*, Pectin, Natural Flavor*, Lemon Juice Concentrate*, Vanilla Beans*, Agar, Live Active Cultures (S. Thermophilus, L. Bulgaricus, L. Acidophilus, Bifidus, L. Lactis, L. Plantarum). *Organic

Allergens: Cashews & Coconut

Smell: it smells like vanilla but also a little chalky

Taste: I tasted vanilla and lemon, but it felt gritty and dry on my tongue, almost like there’s bits of sand. It’s okay but not great.

Chobani Oat Vanilla: 5/10

Nutrition:  130 calories / 3g fat / 6g protein / 12g sugar / 11g added sugar

Ingredients: Oat Blend (Organic Ingredients) (Water, Whole Grain Oats (Organic Ingredients)), Water, Cane Sugar (Organic Ingredients), Tapioca Flour, Coconut (Organic Ingredients), Less than 2% of: Vanilla Extract, Pea Protein (Organic Ingredients), Tapioca Flour (Organic Ingredients), Sunflower Oil (Organic Ingredients), Lemon Juice Concentrate (Organic Ingredients), Fruit Pectin, Locust Bean Gum, Natural Flavors, Cultures. 6 Live and Active Cultures: L. Acidophilus, S. Thermophilus, L. Bulgaricus, L. Casei, L, Helveticus, and Bifidus.

Smell: smells like vanilla

Taste: Nice and smooth, very thin, I notice the aftertaste the most. Still can’t figure out why most of these all have a bad aftertaste! I’m not that into it. It kind of tastes like vanilla on top of oat with that funky aftertaste. Some people might like it more than me but I’m just not that into it.

Icelandic Provisions Oatmilk Skyr Plain: 4/10

Nutrition:  9g fat / 13g protein / 3g added sugar / 2g fiber / 15g carbohydrates

Ingredients: oatmilk, grapeseed oil, natural flavors, live and active cultures

Smell: none detected

Taste: It tastes like oats, it’s not terrible, but I’m not a fan of the aftertaste. I could see maybe using this in a recipe that calls for plain yogurt but wouldn’t eat it on its own.

Oatly Plain: 4/10

Nutrition:  180 calories / 9g fat / 4g protein / 7g sugar / 7g added sugar

Ingredients: Oatmilk (Water, Oats), Low Erucic Acid Rapeseed Oil, Potato Starch, Contains 2% Or Less Of: Dextrose, Pea Protein, Potato Protein, Calcium Carbonate, Guar Gum, Tricalcium Phosphate, Locust Bean Gum, Live Active Cultures (S. Thermophilus, L. Bulgaricus, L. Casei, L. Acidophilus, And B. Lactis).

Smell: mild

Taste: very runny texture, and taste reminded me of Elmer’s Glue. No bitter aftertaste. You could probably mix this into something that calls for yogurt but the taste is not fantastic.

Nancy’s Oatmilk Apple Cinnamon: 2/10

Nutrition:  110 calories / 1.5g fat / 6g protein / 10g sugar

Ingredients: Oatmilk (Water, Whole Oat Flour), Faba Bean Protein, Apple Puree, Organic Cane Sugar, Tapioca Flour, Coconut Oil, Cinnamon Natural Flavor, Agar, Citric Acid, Live Non-dairy Yogurt Cultures: S. Thermophilus, L., Bulgaricas., Live Nondairy Probiotic Cultures: Bifidobacterium Lactis Bb-12, L. Acidophilus, L. Rhamnosus Lgg

Allergens: Tree Nuts (Coconut Oil)

Smell: smells like plastic and vomit

Taste: Like baby food gone wrong. Don’t know how I even tasted it after smelling it. Wondering if I got a bad container?? If I were you I’d try the vanilla but NOT this one.

Kite Hill Greek-style Plain Unsweetened Almond Milk: 1/10

Nutrition:  160 calories / 10g fat / 11g protein / 2g sugar / 0g added sugar

Ingredients: Almond Milk (Water, Almonds), Tapioca Starch, Pectin, Locust Bean Gum, Agar, Live Active Cultures: S. Thermophilus, L. Bulgaricus, L. Acidophilus, Bifidobacteria.

Smell: just smells like almonds

Taste: A touch thicker than regular yogurt, not as thick as traditional Greek yogurt. It tastes like wood flavored glue. Actively bad. Do not recommend.

Looking for more breakfast ideas?

Check out 18 Healthy Toddler Breakfast Ideas from a Registered Dietitian!

5 Comments

Kelly Powers · September 22, 2021 at 4:52 am

I love that you shared this and that you highlighted the amount of sugar in each! There’s so much added sugar in so many items, including yogurt, that most people don’t know to look for.

    Mama Knows Nutrition · September 22, 2021 at 10:58 am

    You’re so right. It’s frustrating on many levels. It’s tough for yogurt companies, because from what I hear, the higher sugar products sell so much better. So it’s like they obviously want to be profitable, but it’s at odds with people getting better nutrition…but it’s not their fault that’s what people buy more of!

Stacie · September 25, 2021 at 5:47 pm

I noticed really only one plain yogurt which you said was bad. Is there anything out there that is like fage or chobani plain greek yogurt? My kid loves this but is showing some dairy intolerances. We use this a lot and would love an equivalent.

    Mama Knows Nutrition · September 26, 2021 at 2:04 pm

    Hi Stacie! Yes, I would try a coconutmilk plain one like so delicious and then you can add in an unflavored collagen peptide powder for protein! I should add that to this post, because someone else asked me about this too- a good plain option. The problem is that they are lacking protein, but you can add that in with a protein powder! I like vital proteins unflavored collagen peptides – https://rstyle.me/+Jr9NUYg5ID8y6-yESP4M3w (affiliate link <3)

Olivia Mia · September 27, 2021 at 2:54 am

Thank you so much for sharing such a great article. It really motivated me a lot. I was really disturbed because of my weight. I have tried many diet plans but it never helped me, but I think your diet plan will help me. I also join a gym last week, I hope that a gym and your diet plan will help me to lose weight.

Leave a Reply

Avatar placeholder

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Hi, I’m Kacie!

I’m a mom of two and a Registered Dietitian Nutritionist. I offer e-guides and e-books (go to my Shop page), workshops, brand partnerships, and nutrition counseling. Check out my blog for nutrition and feeding tips for your little ones.

Search Our Site